The Chinese are Coming!

19 Sep
chinese laborer

Chinese Laborer

The year’s 1973; I’m eighteen and it’s a late Saturday night and I’m returning home from a night of disco dancing with the gang.  I’m asleep all of four hours when on a very early Sunday morning my father pulls the summer sheets off my bed.  “Get up,” he says.  “We leave for work.”  At six in the morning, my eyes half-shut, I report to a construction site near Tel-Aviv.  Arabic is heard all around me.  I help my father mix cement, haul bricks and blocks up the apartment complex.  By noon several walls have gone up, by late afternoon I pack up my tools and walk home with my dad. This is how I spent my summer vacation, working, speaking nothing but Arabic with a bunch of Arab help from the Gaza Strip.

Fast forward to the 1990s, my dad’s near retirement but he’s still working full-time as a bricklayer, not with Arabs, but this time with Romanians.  Arabs are no longer welcome in Israel after a period of terrorist attacks.  Romanians by the thousands take their place.  They’re reliable, cheap, and do not carry bombs in their lunchbox.  And so begins Israel’s love affair with foreign labor.  Tens of thousands of Filipinos are employed here as caregivers to aging Israelis, thousands of Thai immigrants pick produce from fields.  Most Israelis don’t do menial labor.  My father belonged to a bygone era.  Today Israelis would rather work at high-tech jobs, medicine, military hardware, or develop the next killer-app for Silicone Valley. Getting one’s hands dirty in construction jobs is just that – dirty.

Chinese construction laborers in Israel

Chinese construction laborers in Israel

And so begins the next round of immigrant labor to Israel, this time the Chinese.  Homes in Israel are notoriously expensive.  Americans on average have to work 60-70 months to buy a home. Europeans: 80.  Israelis: 140.  Why?  There are many reasons: Jewish immigrants and investors come to Israel in large numbers, adding to demand.  Majority of land is owned by the Israeli government which has a vested interest in keeping land values high so it can get its share of taxes.  To keep demand high, it doles out land gingerly.  High labor costs add to high cost of homes. Demand outstrips supply. Building projects remain idle for lack of laborers.  Jews don’t want to climb scaffolds, to pour concrete, to plaster.  Arabs from the West Bank are suspect.  What’s a developer to do?  Using their strong lobby, the developers recently petitioned the Israeli government to allow “importing” 30,000 Chinese.  They claim the Chinese earn less than Jews and Arabs, and therefore they can pass on the savings to home buyers. Prices will go down by 5%.

Arabs in Construction

Arabs in Construction

This entire plan smells like a week-old chow mein.  Judging from past “import” of foreign labor, there was no price reduction.  On the contrary, prices are still spiraling out of control.  Developers and contractors will pocket the savings and blame the higher prices on others.  Secondly, why do we need 30,000 Chinese?  It’s common knowledge that these poor immigrants pay hefty “transaction fees” to Chinese and Israeli brokers.  Before these Chinese men lift a single brick, they start out with a debt of thousands of dollars, a modern-day slavery.  Yet these Chinese men are willing to cough up the money just so they come and work.

But what about the Arabs?  According to figures, there are 37,000 Arabs who enter daily from the West Bank (Judea and Samaria) to work in Israel proper, and an estimated 13,000 who enter as undocumented laborers.  Unemployment in the West Bank is high.  If Israel is to put out the fire on its turbulent relations with the West Bank Arabs of late, is it not better off employing them?  Will bringing home a paycheck to their villages not help quell the Arabs’ festering anger toward Israel? It’s not my love of the Arabs that convinces me that this is the better solution, but the love of the Jews and what’s best for them/us.

These 50,000 Arab laborers are reliable; they leave their village homes at daybreak, go through security check-points manned by Israeli soldiers; they stand in congested lines for hours before being admitted in, and finally once inside Israel, they build homes for the Jews, return home late in the day to start the whole thing all over again the next day.  When asked on TV if they’re content, the answer is a resounding “yes!”  They earn Israeli Shekels with dignity, return home and feed and care for their families.  Are there bad apples in the bunch? Terrorist cells?  Very few.  The majority want nothing more than to work.  And if 30,000 Chinese are going to land here, what will it do to labor costs?  Arabs will be squeezed further.  They will not be able to provide.  Anger and frustrations will escalate.  One more brick in the wall that will lead to an uprising, an Intifada.  My disco days are long gone, but if the Chinese are allowed to enter and displace Arabs, we could all be dancing to a different tune.  And I didn’t read this in a fortune cookie.


Maurice Labi is an Israeli-American who lived in Los Angeles for many years. In 2011 He returned to Northern Israel (Galilee) with his wife and twin teenage daughters. He is of two lands, of two cultures and he blogs about his experiences in Israel, particularly from Galilee where Jews and Arabs dwelled for centuries.

He has also written three novels: “Jupiter’s Stone,” “Into the Night,” and “American Moth” — available at

or at


10 Responses to “The Chinese are Coming!”

  1. Sandy Galfas September 19, 2015 at 6:36 pm #

    Makes sense, Maurice. The old saw is “make love, not war.” I agree with your new take of the matter: “make work, not war.”

    • Maurice Labi September 19, 2015 at 8:37 pm #

      Yes, keeping people busy gets them out of trouble

  2. Avi September 19, 2015 at 8:56 pm #

    Maurice, exactly a year ago, a young Israeli, a father of two children, who was the owner of a construction company, was murdered by his Arab workers. They cut the cables of his snapling, causing him to fall to his death from the height of the 18th floor. I’m not sure how often such things have happened, but I know this is hardly an isolated case of Israeli employers murdered by their Arab employees. Furthermore, there were MANY cases of Arab construction workers who intentionally sabotaged the work they were doing like plugging plumbing and drainage pipes, causing huge financial damages to the developers. Indeed, employing Arabs is much easier that importing foreign laborers fro afar, but fact is most Israeli employers do no longer want to risk their lives and livelihood. I respect your views. You may hire them and sing kumbaya with them all you want, but most Israeli employers appear to assess the risks differently than you.

    • Maurice Labi September 20, 2015 at 6:29 am #

      Media headlines are sensational. Yes, there are outbursts of violence from time to time, but most times people go about their lives. This can be said of Arabs who lash out at Jews with rocks and molotov cocktails, and it can be said of Jews who burn Arab homes with their occupants inside. It cuts both ways. There are 300,000 Arabs living in Jerusalem (35%), yet the number of violent incidents can be counted on two hands. If Jews and Arabs tend to their livelihood, jobs, and families, they’re less inclined to violence, and this is the tone of this post. Work is honorable, work is good. Deprive man of dignity and he finds something else to do.

  3. Mark September 19, 2015 at 9:41 pm #

    I find this piece interesting on a lot of levels. If the Arab communities begin to develop their own economies it would go a long way toward establishing peace with Israel, since the Arabs would have more of a stake in the game and start employing their own with an emerging economy evolving and improving, but I’m not holding my breath for it to happen in this generation. Also, apparently Israel by importing such huge numbers is establishing relations with Asian nations that will bring, as yet, more business and stronger ties with those countries and lessening the reliance on the U.S.; which during this administration has not demonstrated concerns for Israel’s security, little lone their economy.


    • Maurice Labi September 20, 2015 at 6:36 am #

      We have ample evidence with what’s going on not only with Palestinians but with Arab-Israelis living in Israel proper – the more these Arabs work, the more they’re engaged in their childrens’ school, the more they’re part of the Israeli economy, the lower the birthrate, the higher investment per child, and the higher the chance they’ll stay out of trouble. That’s true of Arabs in Israel, of blacks in America, of immigrants in Europe. As for importing Asians to improve relations with their respective countries, that’s a tall order. Israel is broken up into much too many pieces to allow one more piece to shake up the fragile existence. The real estate developers who wish to bring tens of thousands of Chinese are not thinking of bilateral relations but of their pocket, and when the economy sours, these misrable Chinese will be kicked out on the first plane out.

  4. rivka September 20, 2015 at 6:29 pm #

    Excellent point, Maurice. Well said.
    We need to think of ways to mend relationships with neighbors, not with strangers from China.
    Letting Arabs (and maybe Jews??? ha ha…) do the work , improves economy, keeps prices down, and builds foundation for peace.
    Thanks for highlighting this issue

    • Maurice Labi September 20, 2015 at 7:30 pm #

      Apparently we are in the minority. Today the Israeli government gave the green light to “import” tens of thousands of Chinese to “help the housing market.”

  5. rachel bar September 23, 2015 at 5:58 pm #

    You are eloquent and perceptive as always. Can you start a new party and run for elections?

    • Maurice Labi September 24, 2015 at 4:22 am #

      It’s doubtful anyone will vote or support my line of thinking.

Let me know what you think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: